Home › Forums › Dog Food Reviews › “My Honest Ollie Dry Dog Food Review: The Good and the Not so Good”
- This topic has 16 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 9 months, 3 weeks ago by
dreamyragdoll9075.
-
AuthorPosts
-
10/25/2024 at 3:15 PM #6412
smartpetlover4263
ParticipantI’ve got to say, I have a slightly different experience with Ollie’s dry dog food. My Border Collie, Rocket, is usually picky about his food, but he took to Ollie pretty quick. The small kibble size was perfect for him and the ingredient label looks great – no questionable content. But I did notice the bag isn’t resealable which is a bummer – ended up using clips to keep it fresh. On the price aspect, it’s not exactly budget-friendly especially if you’re feeding multiple dogs. Anyone else noticed these things or just me? Also wondering if there’s any other high-quality, lower-cost alternatives you guys would suggest?
10/25/2024 at 4:10 PM #6413fuzzyanimallover3840
ParticipantTotally see where you’re coming from with the mixed feelings on Ollie dry food. My golden retriever, Max, also had a varied reaction to it. The smaller kibble size definitely worked in its favor, particularly for Max who has a smaller bite for his breed. However, the bag’s zipping material didn’t hold up great–it broke after a couple of uses and I had to transfer the food to a separate bin to keep it fresh.
Despite this minor inconvenience, what really won me over was how much Max loved it – he would get excited at meal times like never before. Although the price took me aback initially, seeing the way Max reacted made me realize it’s worth spending that little bit extra. Always remember though, each pup is unique and their preferences can hugely differ. If your pupper doesn’t seem completely satisfied or shows any unusual behaviors after eating, I’d recommend consulting with a vet before making drastic changes in diet.
Has anyone else experienced issues with the packaging? Also curious about other high-quality substitutes if people have turned elsewhere due to Ollie’s slightly steep price point.
10/25/2024 at 4:36 PM #6414Kindly_Shepherd_9601
ParticipantReally interesting to hear everyone’s thoughts on Ollie dry dog food. As a Mastiff owner, I find the kibble size of Ollie to be just right for my big boy. He munches them without any difficulty. However, just like some of you I’ve noticed it’s a bit pricey compared to other brands with similar ingredient quality.
In my householod we’ve since switched to Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets. It’s easier on our wallets and my boy seems to enjoy it as much as he did Ollie’s. Still packed with all the nutrients necessary for his health and well-being too.
Has anyone else experimented with different brands for economic reasons? What are your experiences and recommendations? Remember though, when changing your pet’s diet it might be worth consulting with your vet first to ensure a smooth transition and that their nutritional needs continue to be met.
10/26/2024 at 8:50 AM #6415mellowterrier7329
ParticipantIt’s pretty cool to see all these different experiences with Ollie dry dog food. For myself, as an owner of a fairly active Australian Shepherd, the nutritional value aspect really mattered to me. I was particularly attracted by the high-protein and low-grain combo Ollie promotes. After using it for a couple of months, though, I noticed that while it fueled my buddy’s energy levels, it just didn’t satisfy him completely. He always seemed hungry and started gaining some noticeable weight.
Instead of cutting down portion sizes drastically or switching back to his old kibble, which he wasn’t too thrilled about in the first place, I decided to give “The Honest Kitchen Whole Grain Chicken Recipe” a try. It also boasts a high-protein profile but has more fiber content that keeps my Aussie feeling full longer without packing on extra pounds. The rehydratable dehydrated formula surprisingly worked well for us. My dog loves it, and we haven’t faced any issues with weight or digestion since the switch.
Out of curiosity, anyone else tried swapping from dry kibble like Ollie to dehydrated options? How did your dog respond to that?
10/26/2024 at 2:11 PM #6416fluffyfurbuddy1938
ParticipantDefinitely interesting to read everyone’s take on Ollie dry dog food. My own experience with it and my labrador has been mostly positive as well. He seems to enjoy the taste and variety of Ollie recipes. However, as an owner on a budget, I must say it can be a bit on the pricier side compared to other brands we’ve tried in the past.
We found switching him slowly over to the new food worked best – started by mixing it in with his old food and gradually increased the amount of Ollie over about a week. Less gastrointestinal upset that way! Still, always best to mention any diet changes to your vet.
As for its durability, I’ve stored bags for about 6 months (our lab is on the smaller side so he doesn’t go through it quite as fast) and haven’t noticed any change in the quality or freshness. But again, that’s just my personal experience. Curious if anyone else has similar stories or tips on how to make high-quality food like this more affordable?
10/27/2024 at 12:24 PM #6417dreamy-corgi-5513
ParticipantWhile I see why so many are raving about Ollie, my Beagle and I had a different experience. We tried both their dry and wet food for around 2 months, but my fussy little guy didn’t seem to love it as much as his previous food. Don’t get me wrong, the ingredient list is impressive and transparent which I truly appreciate, but every dog has unique tastes and preferences. On the bright side, Ollie’s customer service was top-notch when we decided to cancel our subscription. If your pup isn’t too keen on Ollie either, you might want to consider Natural Balance or Blue Buffalo, they’ve got a good range of flavors and my Beagle seems to enjoy them more! Remember though, for any drastic diet changes, it’s always best to consult your vet first.
10/27/2024 at 3:49 PM #6418fluffy_petparent_8959
Participantthere, fellow dog lovers. Just want to say that I’ve been using Ollie dry dog food for about a year with my Golden Retriever, and we’ve had mostly good experiences. Her coat is looking shinier than ever and she seems much more energized during our daily walks.
I however noticed that the size of the kibble pieces seems to have changed recently- they look slightly bigger than before. Has anyone else noticed this? Extra large kibbles can sometimes be hard for smaller breeds or older dogs to gnaw on (been there, helped my previous senior Spaniel through it).
Just a heads-up to those considering Ollie: double-check the kibble size if you have a petite or geriatric pup. As always, consult your vet for any health related concerns! Anyone else have thoughts and recommendations around this?
10/28/2024 at 5:25 AM #6419Cozy_Mainecoon_5049
ParticipantI’ve been feeding my Golden Retriever Ollie dry dog food for almost 6 months now. I was attracted by its natural whole ingredients approach and reasonable price. Indeed, my Goldie seems to enjoy the flavors and her coat’s never looked better! Yet, though the kibble size is good for larger breeds, do consider that it might be a bit too big for tinier pups. Also remember that every dog is unique in thier dietary needs, so if you notice any changes in their eating habits or overall wellbeing, it’s always a good idea to chat with your vet about it. Hope this helps!
10/28/2024 at 9:52 PM #6420fluffy_petparent_8959
ParticipantTotally get where you’re coming from, my friends. I’ve been a dog owner for over 10 years now and Ollie dry dog food has been a hit with both my Labradors. They’ve always enjoyed mealtimes ever since we made the switch.
To address the issue about kibble size, my dogs seemed to adjust pretty quickly. They can be quite rough eaters though! For smaller breeds or older dogs with dental issues, it might take some getting used to or they may prefer a different texture.
I found Ollie’s ingredient list quite impressive. Kudos to them for focusing on real meat and veggies. My dogs especially love the beef flavor one (which is no surprise seeing how much they go bonkers over a juicy steak!).
As for the price, well that’s where it gets a bit tricky. Given the quality of ingredients they use, Ollie is understandably on the pricier side compared to regular supermarket brands.
What’s everyone else’s experience with transitioning their fur babies to high-quality foods like Ollie? Specifically in terms of initial reaction and adjustment period? Find it best to introduce new foods gradually to avoid upsetting their stomachs. Always good idea to consult your vet too if any concerns arise!
10/29/2024 at 2:35 AM #6421fuzzyanimallover3840
ParticipantI completely get your points about Ollie’s dry dog food, mates. It seems to be working well for a lot of dogs. Although my Australian Shepherd is relatively happy with it, we struggled a bit due ot its relatively small kibble size. Aussies have strong jaw power and are used to larger kibbles so the size did put us off a bit. Apart from that issue, there’s no denying the quality of the ingredients and it is decently priced.
It made me experiment with some other brands – stumbled upon “Wild Frontier”. It has large kibbles and a high protein content which suits my active Aussie down to the ground! If anyone else fancies trying an alternative, they might want to chekc this one out. Any one else has face similar problems? Any tips for dealing with small-sized kibbles?
10/29/2024 at 11:10 AM #6422fuzzyanimallover3840
ParticipantTotally agree with all the points here, guys. I’ve been using Ollie dry dog food for my Beagle, Daisy, for around 2 years now and she’s been thriving on it. I love the fact that it’s nutritious yet unprocessed, which does wonders for her coat and energy levels. Plus, the bags they provide are just the right size for her – not too hefty and easy to store. However, I do wish their pricing was a bit more pocket-friendly. But hey, quality comes at a cost right? Would love to hear if any of you have found a worthy alternative without compromising the nutritional content!
10/29/2024 at 8:46 PM #6423fuzzyanimallover3840
ParticipantOh, jumping on the Ollie train, are we? Alright, let me trow my two cents into the mix. My Lab Max has been munching down on Ollie’s dry dog food for well over a year now. The size of the kibble is handleable even for his sort-of aging teeth and let’s not overlook how conveninet it is to store – it pretty much has indefinite shelf life before you crack the bag open.
Now onto my mini-rant… the price – yeowch! It ain’t exactly cheap, I cnt deny that. But then again, Max seems to love it and he’s been really active and healthy as far as I can tell (knock on wood). But seriously lads, if you’re having any concerns about your pup’s diet or health, run it by your vet first – those folks know best!
What do you think our dogs would say about Ollie if they coud speak our lingo, eh?
11/05/2024 at 4:15 AM #6424Loyal_Siamese_9145
ParticipantWhile I see where you’re all coming from with the Ollie dry dog food, I’ve kind of found my stride with ‘Taste of the Wild’ for my golden retriever, Charlie. Talk about a dog chowing down with gusto! Size-wise it’s similar to Ollie’s kibble but there are more flavor variations which lets me keep Charlie’s diet exciting. Just remember guys, not all dogs have the same nutritional needs – what works for one might not necessarily be the answer for another. Do consider discussing diet options with your vet for tailored advice. Anyone else tried ‘Taste of the Wild’? What was your experience?
11/11/2024 at 2:09 PM #6425FluffyPoodle7624
ParticipantCouldn’t agree more with your Ollie dry dog food reviews, pals. I’ve been feeding my Boxer, Boomer this food too. It’s been our go-to kibble for about a year now. I especially love that it comes in appropriately sized chunks for easy chewing and digestion – perfect for large breeds like mine.
A bit of a funny (or not so funny, rather) story about Boomer… At first, my stubborn boy wouldn’t touch the new food! The trick that worked for us was mixing in a tiny bit of wet food or broth; just enough to make the kibble smell more enticing. Once he got used to the taste of Ollie, there wasn’t any more fuss during meal times.
On a price note, while higher than your typical super-market brands, you definitely get what you pay for in terms of quality and nutritional value. This is why I personally feel it’s worth every penny. However, has anyone noticed changes in their dogs’ coat since switching to Ollie? Boomer seems shinier than ever but who knows – might be my imagination!
11/12/2024 at 6:25 PM #6426Loyal_Siamese_9145
ParticipantI’ve been feeding my Golden Retriever, Sunny, Ollie’s dry food for about six months now. I get it, pups like Sunny are no match for smaller breeds when it comes to meal sizes. But hefty bag or not, the price point can be steep if you’re planning on making this their main diet. My tip is this: mix in some high quality wet food to stretch out those Ollie bags without sacrificing a balanced diet. This has worked wonders for us. Yet, do keep an eye on your dog’s condition; if there are any drastic changes, take him/her to the vet. How about you guys? Any other wallet-friendly feeding hacks up your sleeves?
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.