- This topic has 13 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 11 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Well, I thought Grandma Lucy’s were the bee’s knees until I pulled out a packet and my lab, Murphy, turned his nose up at it. Turns out they’re as big as his head! Now don’t get me wrong, Murphy can gulp down food like a black hole when he wants to but these- uh-uh. Just wouldn’t go for it.
Their quality isn’t too bad I suppose but if you’ve got a smaller pooch or one with dental issues, you might want to reconsider – they are pretty rock solid too. My suggestion would be to maybe break them up into smaller sizes or soak ’em in water before feeding. And believe me, Murphy is not usually picky, these just seemed like overkill.
On pricing, well let’s just say that they fall in the “my dog better love them or else” category. So all in all, while these didn’t work out for us in the size and price departments, your mileage may vary.
We’ve now switched to Zesty Paws calming bites. They’re softer and more reasonably priced. Anyone else tried those? Do share your thoughts.
Oh, Grandma Lucy’s… Been there, done that. I too was blindsided by the cool packaging and the healthy promise – until I found my bulldog, Buster, nonchalantly looking at them like they were yesterday’s news. They are little on the pricier side considering thier ‘meh’ performance if you ask me. For a treat to pass muster in our home it needs the three S’s: size, scrumptiousness, and shelf-life. We switched to Wellness Core Marrow Roasts and haven’t looked back since – affordable and consistently gets Buster drooling. Might be worth a shot for Murphy? Just remember to introduce new treats gradually to avoid any tummy troubles. And keep the treats consistent – jumping around multiple brands often backfires in more ways than one!
Boy, can I relate to your experience with Grandma Lucy’s! My corgi, Bella, was obsessed with them at first – she’d do any trick for these treats. The size was perfect, not too big for her small mouth. But then, after a while, she became less enthusiastic and would just leave them untouched. To be honest, I was disappointed given the price and how much she initially loved them.
As far as durability is concerned, they do last long if stored properly. But what’s the point if your pooch doesn’t munch on ’em anymore? I found an alternate – ‘Buddy Bits’, they are cost-effective and Bella hasn’t gotten over them yet. Besides, you might want to consult a vet while transitioning to a new brand of treats. Just my two cents!
Have any of you tried ‘Buddy Bits’? How did your dogs like it?
Oh, Murphy and Bella are definitely not alone! I also fell for Grandma Lucy’s due to their catchy packaging but soon found out they weren’t that fantastic when their magic wore off on Rosie, my Boxer. The treats seemed fine at first – nice size, plant-based materials, seemingly durable. But like you guys noted, Rosie just lost interest after a couple weeks. Honestly considering the price point, I expected way more durability. My advice? Maybe mix these treats up with others so your dog doesn’t get bored as fast. Anyone else tries this approach with any success? Let a guy know! Oh and remember, if your pups aren’t eating or reacting weirdly to new treatst, always consult the vet!
I’ve been using Grandma Lucy’s dog treats for quite some time now and my terrier, Rex, simply loves them! They seem to be the right size for him and he enjoys the crunch. But I also noticed that they’re a bit pricier compared to other brands we have tried before. As for durability, they do hold up well in the treat jar without crumbling down or spoiling too soon. All in all, it’s a good treat – just watch out for the price tag!
I’ve got to add my two cents here too. My golden retriever, Max, is positively crazy about Grandma Lucy’s. What really wins me over is the size of the treats which are just perfect for training sessions. They’re small enough to keep his attention without overfeeding him and they seem to be gentle on his stomach too.
As for durability, we’ve found that they held up fairly well even in the warm weather and didn’t crumble in our treat bag, which is definitely a plus in my book.
Price-wise, they may seem a tad pricey compared to some other options out there, but considering their quality and how much Max loves them, I think it’s totally worth it. Oh and if anyone’s new to these delights, I’d recommend starting with the pumpkin-flavored ones – they were an instant hit with my boy. What flavors have been a hit with your pooches?
Well, ain’t it the truth that our four-legged pals simply can’t get enough of Grandma Lucy’s. My Basset hound, Lulu completely goes gaga over them no matter the flavor it seems. From a human point of view, I do appreciate their convenience in size and that they’re easy to break apart for making portion control easier during training or when you just want to treat your pup without overdoing it. On the flipside though, they’re ain’t exactly cheap – but hey, anything for our beloved poochs right? Anyone else feel the shiver run down their wallet every time their dog drools at these treats?
So, here’s another perspective for your consideration – I’ve picked up these treats for my bulldog, Bruno, who is quite the picky eater. Grandma Lucy’s dog treats are undoubtedly well-made and high quality, but I found them to slightly be on the pricier side given their size. Considering that, I started purchasing another brand called “Doggo Delights” that also makes grain-free, all-natural treats which Bruno devours in no time. Perhaps, you could give it a shot if you’re looking for something more budget-friendly that doesn’t compromise on quality? Just curious, has anyone else explored other affordable alternatives?
Agreement: Couldn’t agree more about the appeal of Grandma Lucy’s treats – I’ve got a stubborn old beagle who turns his nose up at most goodies, but he positively drools for these. He can’t get enough of the pumpkin-flavored ones especially. I really appreciate that they’re made from quality ingredients and are quite durable too. It gives me peace of mind knowing that I’m giving him something that he adores and which isn’t just junk food.
Question: Does anyone have any ideas on how to ration these out? My buddy would eat the whole bag in one go if given half a chance (not that I’d let him!). How many treats do your guys suggest for daily consumption?
I have to admit, my Goldendoodle pup loves Grandma Lucy’s treats. The size is excellent for training sessions; not too big that he gets full too fast, yet satisfying enough to keep his interest peaked. One thing I’ve noticed, however, is that they can be a bit crumbly – well, at least when they’re handled by over-excited puppy paws! For smaller pups or those on a stricter diet, always consider a dog’s overall calorie intake and portion these accordingly. The price does lean towards the high end, but in my opinion, it is absolutely worth it considering the quality and how much my fur baby enjoys them!
Absolutely! Grandma Lucy’s treats are a hit in my household as well. In terms of size, I find them to be just right for both my Pomeranian and Golden Retriever – quite the versatile treat! And yes, they’ve proven invaluable for training sessions. Ever since we started using them, our little Pom has really upped his game on the obedience front. Plus, with their great price point, they’re pretty easy on the wallet too! Has anyone tried using them as a meal topper? I’m curious if dogs love them just as much scattered over their usual food.
Absolutely on board with you all about Grandma Lucy’s! I’ve been using them as training rewards for my energetic Cocker Spaniel, Milo, and he adores them. They are indeed a perfect size for a little “good boy” treat without spoiling his dinner. Plus, the ingredient list is quite clean and simple. No unnecessary additives or scary chemicals. Certainly gives me peace of mind knowing I’m not feeding my pup anything harmful.
One thing I’d recommend to other dog owners, especially those with smaller breeds – keep an eye out when opening a new bag. Some pieces can be a little larger than others so I usually break those up into tinier bits to prevent any possible choking hazard. Otherwise, definitely a win in our household!
Anyone else have crafty ways they use these treats in their training regime? Always open to new strategies! 🙂
Agreeing with everyone here about the size annd quality of Grandma Lucy’s treats. They’ve been a tremendous help in our potty training journey with our new rescue, Bruno. The mini-size treats work fantastic as a high-value reward without risking overfeeding him. One thing I particularly appreciate is that these are oven-baked and free from artificial preservatives, giving me confidence I’m offering something wholesome to my furry buddy.
As advice for those considering buying, do remember their value pack might seem pricier upfront but it works out more economical in the long run.
Has anyone tried their freeze-dried fruit range? Wondering if it’s as hit as the regular ones.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.